Best Buffalo Grill desserts

1829 duels later, Leslie's Brownie is still #1 in the Buffalo Grill desserts ranking, with Giant Pancakes close behind.

Leslie's Brownie edges out Giant Pancakes by just 3 points at 1339 ELO, winning 65% of its duels. The podium shows a tight race: Giant Pancakes at 1336 ELO holds off Cheesecake by a larger margin of 18 points, the ranking's sharpest gap. Below the top three, Vanilla Cookie Caramel Sundae and Mousse Gourmande round out the top five with 1305 and 1302 ELO respectively. At the bottom, coffee-based desserts struggle: Irish Coffee ranks 22nd with 977 ELO and a 26% win rate, narrowly ahead of Café du Shérif at 976 ELO. Ananas Florida sits last at 24th with 931 ELO, suggesting Buffalo Grill diners prefer chocolate and cream over fruit and caffeine.

This ranking draws from 1829 duels between 24 desserts, with 27 players weighing in on which treat makes them drool the most. Updated on 12 October 2026, it reflects the preferences of a community that clearly leans toward indulgent, rich desserts over lighter options. The tight race at the top means a few votes could reshuffle the podium. Cast your vote to shape the next update and settle the brownie versus pancake debate.

Updated on October 12, 2026

How this ranking is computed

Every duel won lifts a contender and every loss drops them, by an amount that depends on the opponent's strength: beating the leader is worth more than beating the last. It is an ELO, the same principle as in chess. Duels are not drawn at random — an adaptive entropy sort puts the least predictable match-ups first, which settles the ranking far faster than a full round robin. A worldwide ranking is only published past 30 completed plays. Known limit: a contender who has faced few opponents keeps an approximate score, and the bottom of the table moves more than the podium.

How our rankings are made →